Author Archives: jamie

The Wild Geese delivers spirited response to Bacardi

The Wild Geese has told WIPR that it disputes comments made by Bacardi in relation to the spirit companies’ ongoing trademark feud.

Last week WIPR reported that the dispute between The Wild Geese and Bacardi goes back to 2014, with the latest developments centring on three open letters the whiskey brand has addressed to Bacardi.

The long-running battle between the spirit companies revolves around The Wild Geese’s logo ‘Untamed’ (US trademark number 87,191,609), registered in international classes 32 and 33, for beverages including beer and spirits. The Untamed brand tells the story of the ‘wild geese’, the name given to the Irish diaspora.

In 2013 Bacardi launched its ‘Bacardi Untameable’ marketing campaign, using it to tell the story of the allegedly “untameable” Bacardi family. It filed to register ‘Bacardi Untameable’ as a trademark in international class 33 for alcoholic beverages.

The Wild Geese filed an opposition with the US Patent and Trademark Office, claiming the campaign misappropriated its ‘Untamed’ mark.

The opposition has been suspended in light of The Wild Geese’s lawsuit against Bacardi for trademark infringement relating to the same ‘Untamed’ mark. The complaint was filed in August 2016 in the US District Court for the Central District of California.

During February 2018 the whiskey company published three open letters to Bacardi, each requesting a response because The Wild Geese has “asked nicely but you didn’t answer”.

Speaking to WIPR a spokesperson for Bacardi said it has constantly prevailed against The Wild Geese’s legal challenges to its ‘Untameable’ trademark. They said the open letters are “clearly issued to attempt to adversely influence the legal process” and “Bacardi will continue to vigorously protect its rights”.

Subsequently a representative for The Wild Geese spoke to WIPR and claimed to be “intrigued” by Bacardi’s comment.

In response to Bacardi’s assertion that it prevailed against legal challenges, The Wild Geese said “Bacardi’s originally successful attempt to move the jurisdiction from California to Miami, their power base, was immediately reversed when the court was made aware of the conflicting statements” made by the spirits company “in order to achieve their aim”.

The spokesperson explained that The Wild Geese is not seeking to adversely influence public opinion but is “merely stating the facts”, which must “make for uncomfortable reading for Bacardi”. They added that the public should decide whether Bacardi’s behaviour in relation to trademarks owned by others is acceptable.

The whiskey company went on to say that “Bacardi demands adherence from others” in respect of US trademark law, yet “seems positively outraged at the idea that the law applies to them also”.

When asked by WIPR to clarify the comments disputed by The Wild Geese, Bacardi declined to comment any further.

https://www.worldipreview.com/news/the-wild-geese-delivers-spirited-response-to-bacardi-15517

Open Letter #3 from Lodestar Wild Geese to Bacardi About (In)Consistency

Open Letter #3 from Lodestar Wild Geese to Bacardi About (In)Consistency

LOS ANGELES, Feb. 14, 2018 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Lodestar Anstalt today issued the following statement:

We asked nicely but you didn’t answer, so we were forced to ask again in court. We’ve distilled some key points from those legal documents and the public record.

Dear Bacardi,

Let’s be honest. Inconsistency was never good, but people got away with it because different audiences had no way of comparing notes. Not so anymore, when there’s an instant and everlasting record on the Internet.

That’s why we sued you for trademark infringement after you apparently took our UNTAMED® trademark and ad campaign, then used it for your own rum products without permission.

Lodestar’s UNTAMED® advertising campaign tells the story of The Wild Geese, a reference to the Irish Diaspora who were forced to leave Ireland yet remained defiant in the face of exile. In your UNTAMEABLE version, you claim that the Bacardi family was exiled, outlawed, and imprisoned.  Is that your real heritage, or did you “borrow” that from us, too?

Bacardi’s own websites tell seemingly contradictory stories about its history. Is no one fact-checking, or at least cross-checking?

Consider these snippets:

In one version, when Bacardi was kicked out of Cuba and its assets were seized after the Cuban Revolution, “The Bacardis lost their business and their home, but … not their spirit. They simply started over somewhere else.” The picture that paints suggests the Bacardi family was near-destitute. That version appears on bacardilimited.com and is the story told in the Bacardi Unatmeable advertising campaign.

Hop over to bacardi.com and there’s a different twist on the story — that Bacardi was aware troubles were brewing for its business, so it shifted assets out of Cuba beforehand. “The company exhibited keen foresight,” the website crows, “having already moved its trademarks and yeast strain out of Cuba for safekeeping. It also had an established multi-national presence and continued operations from several other countries.” In addition, according to published reports, Bacardi received approximately $350 million in subsidies from U.S. taxpayers.

Feeling confused? Double-vision making you queasy, as if you’ve had a few too many swigs of rum?

Then there’s the matter of the value of Bacardi’s Cuban assets and compensation. That’s always been a bit fuzzy.

How much had Bacardi claimed those assets were worth prior to the revolution — which was the basis for any taxes it paid to Cuba? By comparison, how much did Bacardi claim those same assets were worth after they’d been seized and it was seeking compensation?

These are just some of the questions Bacardi, for the first time, will have to answer in United States federal court.

We’re awaiting your answers.

Feeling Plundered,
Lodestar Anstalt, Maker of Untamed® Revolutionary Rum and The Wild Geese Soldiers and Heroes® Irish Whiskey and other fine liquors

Contact:
Andre J. Levy, Chairman
Lodestar Anstalt
bacardiexposed@protonmail.com
+41 794871795

Photos accompanying this announcement are available at
http://www.globenewswire.com/NewsRoom/AttachmentNg/9c142b4c-6d0f-4c0c-a258-4d49752780b7

http://www.globenewswire.com/NewsRoom/AttachmentNg/ba46dc7e-0356-4075-a7ae-9b7b74e38c5f

An Open Letter from Lodestar Wild Geese to Bacardi (globenewswire.com)

n

LOS ANGELES, Feb. 05, 2018 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Lodestar Anstalt today issued the following statement:

We asked nicely but you didn’t answer, so we were forced to ask again in court. We’ve distilled some key points from those legal documents and the public record.

Dear Bacardi,

We’ve heard Bacardi called a “Trademark Pirate of the Caribbean.” We didn’t want to believe it. But now that our trademark has been pillaged, we wonder.

It seems a trend may exist. We wonder what bounds it has — if any.

Perhaps most (in)famously, Bacardi co-opted the iconic photo of Apollo 11 astronaut Buzz Aldrin, the second man to walk on the moon, with the Sea of Tranquility landing site, lunar horizon, and void of space reflected in the visor of his spacesuit.

Bacardi decided to improve the “visor shot” in an ad campaign depicting a bottle of rum pouring its contents onto an image of Aldrin with the lower half of his body adorned in swim trunks and fins. Aldrin, a recovering alcoholic, wasn’t amused. After Bacardi co-opted the achievements of this extraordinary man of courage for its own commercial benefit, Aldrin felt compelled to sue to stop misappropriation of his image and identity. Bacardi ultimately settled and apologized, after public backlash.

Then there’s Bacardi’s two-decade, back-and-forth battle with Pernod Ricard and its Cuban partner over ownership of the Havana Club rum trademark. Even now, you are still arguing over who makes the “real” Cuban rum and accusing Pernod of profiting from a “stolen” trademark.

Congress members are even currently involved in helping Bacardi seek to overturn a ruling that was in favor of the other side. A United States Representative from Florida (where Bacardi’s U.S. operations are based) said the U.S. needs to “honor our nation’s intellectual property laws and policies.”

One wonders, Does Bacardi believe that honoring U.S. intellectual property laws is the right thing to do when Bacardi is the one being accused of expropriating someone else’s trademark?

Which brings us to us.

A few years back, Bacardi was apparently looking to re-brand itself and challenge consumer perceptions that Bacardi was
“for girls and douche bags,” ( Click here to see the document Bacardi’s agency tried to hide since our expose of what the agency reports the consumer really thinks about Bacardi ) according to Bacardi’s brand activation agency. Bacardi apparently liked our trademark Untamed® based on the true story of The Wild Geese — the name given to the Irish diaspora forced to flee Ireland in 1691 and their defiance in the face of exile with acts of real sacrifice and heroism. So Bacardi created the Bacardi Untameable advertising campaign — a reference to its purported hardship after fleeing Cuba.

Click here to see the document Bacardi’s agency tried to hide since our expose of what the agency reports the consumer really thinks about Bacardi

 

 

Like Buzz Aldrin, we weren’t amused. We sued you, claiming trademark infringement and unfair competition. That lawsuit is making its way through federal court.

These trademark cases are notable.

What about lesser-known ones that drift by barely detected, such as when Bacardi (maker of Grey Goose vodka) in 2016 shot down an effort by a competitor to market Goose Green, a vodka named for a battle in the Falklands War? A settlement was reached, and Goose Green never got off the ground. How many others have there been?

Finally, Bacardi must answer these questions and more in U.S. court. Until now, you’ve been able to comfortably shield yourself behind a Bermuda facade. No longer. For the first time, a federal judge has ruled that parent company Bacardi Limited must answer under U.S. legal jurisdiction.

Nothing to hide, is there? Or is shining any light too bright and undesirable?

We’re anxiously awaiting your answers.

Feeling Plundered,
Lodestar Anstalt, Maker of Untamed® Revolutionary Rum and The Wild Geese Soldiers and Heroes® Irish Whiskey and other fine liquors

Contact:
Andre J. Levy, Chairman
Lodestar Anstalt
bacardiexposed@protonmail.com
+41 794871795

https://globenewswire.com/news-release/2018/02/05/1332688/0/en/An-Open-Letter-from-Lodestar-Wild-Geese-to-Bacardi.html